PhotoVoice worked in partnership with Christian Aid as part of their on-going programme BRACED, which builds the resilience of vulnerable communities to climate extremes and disasters in high-risk locations of Ethiopia.
The project aims to build individual capacity within vulnerable communities, enabling their insights to inform future activities for the BRACED programme, and ensuring their voices will be included in the development of future climate change resilience building programmes.
PhotoVoice delivered workshops to community members in the Oromia region of southern Ethiopia, training 11 Local Community Monitors to use photography to capture the benefits, challenges and successes experienced through the BRACED programme over its first year.
Climate change is having significant impact on climate extremes in East and West Africa. It is increasing the frequency and intensity of droughts, and threatening already vulnerable livelihoods and the existence of some remote rural villages. It is also undermining the traditional indicators (such as livestock behaviour) that farmers in these regions have used to predict the weather and seasonal climate, limiting their capacity to adapt and protect their livelihoods.
In rural Ethiopia, these challenges are made worse by community dependency on livestock and agriculture, limited access to externally generated weather and climate information, and the low capacity of communities to respond to climate extremes.
Barriers to communities responding to climate-related shocks include misconceptions and a lack of knowledge surrounding the causes of problems such as drought; attitudes and social norms among some groups which discourage changes, such as livestock reduction and crop diversification; as well as low levels of resources to respond to these threats.
BRACED is a DFID-funded programme which began in 2015 and which aims to help people build resilience to climate-related threats in 13 countries. Christian Aid is leading two consortiums in Ethiopia and has partnered with local NGO HUNDEE to deliver BRACED initiatives to pastoralist communities in Adegalchet, Oromia.
In order to record the progress of the project, Christian Aid partnered with PhotoVoice to provide selected community members with cameras and training as Local Community Monitors. In August 2015, PhotoVoice began by training staff from local partner organisations in participatory photography theory and practice, providing new skills which will be utilised by the organisations in their ongoing engagement work.
PhotoVoice then travelled to the Adegalchat locality in the Yabello District, where participants representing a wide cross-section of the Adegalchet community were provided with participatory photography training and a platform to voice their opinions. This helped identify the most important developmental and climate change issues affecting their community, and establish key evaluation areas based on their personal experiences, expectations, fears and aspirations regarding these issues.
Over the course of the next year, these Local Monitors will document their experiences of change within their community and lives as a result of BRACED project, promoting participant and partner learning and providing insight which can inform future BRACED programming.
Evaluation and Feedback:
When asked, 100% of participants reported an increased confidence in their ability to take photos and caption them to share their feelings and opinions about their community and the impact of BRACED.
Following the workshops, all participants reported an increased confidence in working independently in their new roles as Local Monitors. 100% of participants reported an increased with climate change issues and their communities’ capacity to address these issues.
“Previously, information was shared in words, but this practice is better as photographs can speak and create more sound than words […] The training has enhanced our community’s awareness about the impact of climate change and we are now engaged to consider the measures that should be taken to reduce its impact.”
– Project Participant
The workshops provided valuable insight into the direct impacts of severe weather on livelihoods and contributing factors which can limit or expand capacity to cope with climate change. This included local knowledge on opportunities to build resilience and minimise the community’s vulnerability to these impacts. A local community engagement event and exhibition showcased selected Local Monitor baseline photographs to celebrate the achievement of participants.
The exhibition was attended by the participants themselves, and members of the community, community leaders and Elders and members, and representatives from local government and other NGOs, and was a powerful opportunity to inform the wider community about the participatory photography project and community monitor network, and spread awareness of the aims and activities of the BRACED project.
The Village Head reflected on the impact of climate change to the community and the value of projects such as PhotoVoice in highlighting these issues and amplifying the voice to those directly affected by them:
“In the past, we have experienced so many different interventions from NGOs. The PhotoVoice project was different and stood out as it supported the community to tell their story through photos. I greatly appreciate the hard work that the Local Monitors and trainers have done in raising important issues – we are proud of them and, as a whole community, it has helped us realise the problems we have so that we can work towards finding solutions.”
In March 2016, Projects Manager Kate Watson returned to Yabello to conduct follow up field work which focused on the evaluation of the project. The participatory evaluation workshops captured the experiences of Local Monitors and provided insight into the impact of the PhotoVoice project in Christian Aid’s ongoing participatory monitoring and evaluation the BRACED programme, informing recommendations for the further future incorporation of the participatory photography approaches in future BRACED programme activities.
In the Adegalchat community, strong progress has been made in addressing issues relating to climate change and increased resilience to cope with the changes this issue brings . The project has successfully managed to build the individual capacity of Adegalchat community members, creating a strong group of skilled Local Community Monitors who are now able to include their own, and the wider community’s voices in the development of climate change resilience building interventions.
The images produced provide a clear picture of the issues around extreme and/or erratic weather events at both a personal and community level, and offer valuable insight into the ways in which communities like Adegalchat can work with Christian Aid and local implementation partners, HUNDEE to adapt and modify behaviour in response to the challenges climate change brings.
Participants report increased agency in identifying and communicating priority areas for development and climate change adaption, and their work has led to an increased awareness of the issues and resilience building strategies in the wider community.
Increasingly, participants are able to communicate their priorities and perspectives and have influence at various levels of decision-making, including HUNDEE, the community and at a local and Wordea governance level, both in relation to issues around the BRACED programme and in other community priorities.
“Though we are illiterate, we have studied hard during our training, we have discussed the challenges of this work and explored the solutions. Were can use these skills to explore and communicate issues- property, drought and resource management. Now we are ready and equipped to cooperate with HUNDEE and engage in representing out community … We are able to participate.”
– Local Monitor
“They don’t just take photos to show the challenges the community and they as individuals face, but they have also become analytical and critical in their description of the images and their captions, using them to propose solutions and promote behaviour change. This gives us hope as Administrators that with support, the community has the capacity and potential to be involve and direct positive change.”
– Wordea Administration Government
Local partner HUNDEE credited PhotoVoice’s approach as an extremely useful monitoring and evaluation tool, providing their organisation with new insights into the experiences and expertise of their beneficiaries, and are keen to explore its potential in ongoing communications and advocacy work.
Christian Aid published images from the project at Medium:
Ethiopia Through a Lens – Christian Aid
Header Image: © Ganyu Duba Barangudo 2016 | PhotoVoice | Christian Aid | ‘BRACED’ | Ethiopia
“Today this is empty land but formally it was grazing land. It seems we are in danger as this soil and dryness signals the coming of drought. There are no trees to protect the soil and it has been used by too many livestock who have depleted it.”